Solving Shopify's Google Search Console Indexing Headaches: A Community Deep Dive
Hey there, fellow store owners! We've all been there: you log into Google Search Console, ready to see your hard work paying off, and instead, you're greeted with a sea of red and yellow warnings about indexing issues. It can feel like a punch to the gut, right? Recently, a store owner named royloglobe shared their GSC woes in the Shopify Community, listing a bunch of common issues like "Crawled – currently not indexed," 404s, and redirects. The good news? The community rallied, and we got some fantastic insights that I want to break down for you.
What I love about these discussions is how they cut through the noise. As Roman79 (and others like muhammadyousaf1 and Mustafa_Ali) pointed out, many of these GSC warnings are actually pretty normal for a Shopify store. It's not about fixing every single one by count alone, but understanding what each category means and which ones truly need your attention. Let's dig into the common culprits and how to tackle them, drawing from the brilliant advice shared.
Deciphering Your Google Search Console Report
Royloglobe's report for royloglobe.com showed these categories:
- Crawled – currently not indexed (5 pages)
- Discovered – currently not indexed (6 pages)
- Blocked by robots.txt (3 pages)
- Page with redirect (20 pages)
- Not found (404) (15 pages)
Let's take them one by one.
"Blocked by robots.txt" – Usually Nothing to Worry About
This one often causes the most panic, but for Shopify, it's typically harmless. As MaryJane005, muhammadyousaf1, and PinFlow all emphasized, Shopify intentionally blocks pages like /cart, /checkout, /admin, and /search in its default robots.txt file. You wouldn't want these showing up in search results anyway!
What to do:
- In Search Console, click on this status and look at the specific URLs.
- If they are cart, checkout, account, search, or filtered collection links, you can safely ignore them.
- Only if you see an important product, collection, or content page in this list should you investigate. In such rare cases, you might need to adjust your
robots.txt.liquidfile, but honestly, it's best to leave the default alone unless you're absolutely sure you know what you're doing.
"Page with Redirect" – Standard Housekeeping
Twenty pages with redirects might sound like a lot, but this is also very common on Shopify. It often means old product URLs, variant URLs, or even /collections/.../products/... URLs that are correctly redirecting to the cleaner, final product URL. As LoopcairnLabs pointed out, redirects from HTTP to HTTPS or from www to your main domain are also normal and handled automatically by Google over time.
What to do:
- Export the list of URLs from Search Console.
- Check your internal links (menus, blog posts, product descriptions) to ensure they point to the final, non-redirecting URLs. This helps Google crawl more efficiently.
"Not Found (404)" – Tackle These Strategically
Fifteen 404 errors can impact user experience and SEO. These are typically old product pages you've deleted or URLs that have changed. LoopcairnLabs highlighted that these are addresses Google *tried* to fetch, not necessarily links currently on your site.
Cyrus5 gave a great example for royloglobe, identifying specific dead product handles that needed redirecting to relevant live products, rather than just the homepage.
What to do:
- In Search Console, click on the "Not found (404)" status and export the list of URLs.
- For each URL, determine if it was a real page that moved or was deleted.
- For pages that moved or were deleted but have a relevant replacement, set up a 301 redirect. Don't redirect everything to your homepage! Redirect to the most relevant collection or product page.
- Here's how to create a redirect in Shopify, as shown by PinFlow:

- Go to your Shopify admin > Online Store > Navigation > URL Redirects.
- Click Create URL redirect.
- Type the old path in Redirect from (e.g.,
/products/old-product-handle). - Type the new path in Redirect to (e.g.,
/products/new-product-handleor/collections/relevant-collection). - Click Save redirect.

- After setting up redirects, go back to Search Console and click Validate fix for the 404 status.
"Crawled – currently not indexed" & "Discovered – currently not indexed" – Your Priority!
This is where your real attention should go. These pages are known to Google, but for some reason, Google has chosen not to include them in its search results. As Roman79 and muhammadyousaf1 pointed out, this often happens with thin content, duplicate pages, or pages Google deems not valuable enough. For royloglobe, Cyrus5 found some very specific issues:
- Duplicate Blog Articles: Five articles competing for the same search intent (e.g., "how to seal mylar bags"). Google will only index one.
- Thin Product Pages: Two product pages with only 78-81 words of description, significantly less than other products (300-400 words). Google might prefer to index the collection page over such thin product pages.
What to do:
- Identify Important Pages: First, look at the URLs in these categories. Are they important product pages, collection pages, or key blog posts that you absolutely want to rank? Filtered collection pages or tag pages often fall into these categories and can often be left alone if they aren't critical for organic search.
- Consolidate Duplicate Content: If you have multiple blog posts or pages covering very similar topics, choose the most comprehensive one (Cyrus5 recommended the 1,396-word article for royloglobe) and 301 redirect the others into it. This consolidates link equity and tells Google which page is the definitive source.
- Bulk Up Thin Content: For product pages or articles that are "thin," add more unique, descriptive, and helpful content. Aim for at least 200-300 words for product descriptions. Include unique titles, meta descriptions, and rich media.
- Improve Internal Linking: Make sure these pages are linked from your main menu, homepage, or other relevant, high-authority pages within your site. Strong internal linking signals importance to Google.
- Request Indexing: After making improvements, go to Google Search Console, use the URL Inspection tool for each specific page, and click "Request Indexing." Remember, do this for your *important* pages, not every single URL.
- Be Patient: As MaryJane005 and PinFlow advised, SEO takes time. Give Google 2 to 4 weeks to re-crawl and re-evaluate your pages after you've made changes.
Ultimately, tackling these indexing issues is about being smart and strategic. Don't get overwhelmed by the sheer numbers in GSC. Instead, understand what each category signifies for a Shopify store, prioritize the issues that affect your most important content, and apply the fixes diligently. The community's insights clearly show that by focusing on unique, valuable content and sensible redirects, you can guide Google to index the pages that truly matter for your business. Keep an eye on those reports, and you'll see your efforts pay off!