Shopify Forms Face-Off: Finding the Perfect Submission Solution for Your Store

Shopify Form Frustrations: You're Not Alone!

Let's be honest, sometimes the default Shopify options just don't cut it. I was browsing the Shopify Community the other day and saw a thread started by TravelingBags titled "Looking for Form Advice." They were pretty clear: the built-in Shopify forms weren't doing the trick. And honestly, I've been there. It seems a lot of store owners hit the same wall when they need something beyond basic contact info.

TravelingBags needed a form that could handle basic info, photo uploads (essential for repair requests!), and, most importantly, a way to easily track and manage submissions beyond just getting an email. They wanted a backend system to see what's been submitted, mark requests as completed, and generally keep things organized.

Diving into the Community Solutions

So, what did the community suggest? There were a few different angles thrown out there, and each has its pros and cons, depending on your needs and tech skills.

Option 1: The Free (But Potentially Limited) Route

tim_1 suggested using the free Shopify Forms app in combination with Shopify Flow. This is an interesting approach! The Forms app does allow for file uploads and creates a metaobject for each submission. That's a plus. Then, you can use Flow to trigger actions based on those metaobjects, like sending yourself an email notification. Here are the links tim_1 shared:

• Shopify Forms app: https://apps.shopify.com/shopify-forms
• Forms dox: https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/promoting-marketing/create-marketing/forms-app
• Shopify Flow app: https://apps.shopify.com/flow
• Flow dox: https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/shopify-flow
• Reacting to forms submission with flow: https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/promoting-marketing/create-marketing/forms-app/flow

The potential downside? It might require a bit of setup and configuration to get everything working exactly as TravelingBags (and maybe you!) need. It really depends on how comfortable you are with metaobjects and setting up workflows in Flow.

if my post is helpful, please like it ♡ and mark as a solution -- this will help others find it

Option 2: Exploring Paid Apps

Several community members suggested looking at paid apps in the Shopify App Store. Shadab_dev recommended checking out apps like Zeno (though they didn't explicitly endorse it). Moeed suggested Powerful Contact Form Builder. The big advantage here is that these apps are often more feature-rich and user-friendly than the built-in options. They often come with built-in submission management, easier form building, and better customization options.

The downside, of course, is the monthly subscription cost. But as TravelingBags pointed out, they're willing to pay if it works and solves their problem. Shadab_dev made a great point about trying out free trials to see what fits best.

Option 3: The Custom Code Route

Moeed also mentioned the possibility of custom coding a solution with the help of a Shopify developer. This gives you the ultimate flexibility to build exactly what you need. However, it's also the most expensive and time-consuming option. It really only makes sense if you have very specific requirements that can't be met by existing apps.

Shadab_dev also mentioned emailjs as a free option with custom code, but that option is limited to 200 submissions.

So, What's the Best Approach?

Honestly, it depends on your specific needs and resources. Here's a quick breakdown:

• Tight budget and willing to tinker? Explore the free Shopify Forms app and Shopify Flow. Be prepared to spend some time setting things up.
• Need a user-friendly solution with good features and willing to pay a monthly fee? Check out the paid form builder apps in the Shopify App Store. Take advantage of free trials!
• Have very specific requirements that can't be met by existing apps and have a budget for development? Consider custom coding a solution.

For TravelingBags' specific needs (photo uploads, submission management, and the ability to mark requests as completed), I'd lean towards exploring the paid app options first. The time saved and ease of use might be worth the monthly cost. But definitely take advantage of those free trials to find the perfect fit!

Ultimately, finding the right form solution for your Shopify store is about balancing features, ease of use, and cost. Hopefully, this breakdown of the community's advice helps you make the right decision!